The Climate Diplomacy Paradox: Channeling USD 1 Billion into TFFF, Yet Indonesia’s Natural Forests Are Threatened by PSN Expansion

The Climate Diplomacy Paradox: Channeling USD 1 Billion into TFFF, Yet Indonesia’s Natural Forests Are Threatened by PSN Expansion

Behind the pledge of trillions of rupiah in funding for the global forest endowment fund (TFFF), the expansion of National Strategic Projects (PSN) instead risks slashing Indonesia’s potential benefits due to deforestation penalties

Behind the pledge of trillions of rupiah in funding for the global forest endowment fund (TFFF), the expansion of National Strategic Projects (PSN) instead risks slashing Indonesia’s potential benefits due to deforestation penalties

No headings found on page

Indonesia’s reaffirmation of its USD 1 billion funding commitment to the Tropical Forests Forever Facility (TFFF) during the Leaders' Summit Event on Forests at the 31st Climate Change Conference (COP31) in Antalya, Turkey, on Wednesday (November 11, 2026), marks a pivotal chapter in the nation's climate diplomacy.

The commitment, equivalent to more than IDR 16 trillion, was first announced by the Indonesian government at the 2025 COP30 conference in Belém, Brazil, and has since been echoed across various international forums as proof of Indonesia’s global leadership in tropical forest conservation.

This move places Indonesia alongside Brazil as a key sponsoring nation seeking to mobilize a global endowment fund to safeguard the world's forest ecosystems.

The Domestic Paradox: Deforestation Pressures Behind National Strategic Projects

Yet behind the thunderous applause on the international diplomatic stage in Turkey and Brazil lies a stark paradox that the domestic public cannot afford to ignore.

Aerial photograph showing the boundary of the forest area that has been and will continue to be cleared for PT Papua Agro Lestari's oil palm plantation concession in Ulilin District, Merauke Regency, South Papua, in 2016. Photo: Mighty Earth / Auriga Nusantara

The reality of forest conditions on the ground paints a picture that stands in sharp contrast to the climate-saving narrative brought to the global negotiating table. Even as the government pledges trillions of rupiah to protect the world’s forests, deforestation rates in Indonesia remain shadowed by severe threats from large-scale development expansion.

Various natural forest monitoring datasets from recent years indicate that pressures on forest cover are no longer dominated solely by traditional monoculture plantation expansion, but have shifted toward projects legitimized in the name of national development.

The development of large-scale food estates, connectivity infrastructure, and land clearing for energy transition projects and mining downstreaming under the framework of National Strategic Projects (PSN) have eroded millions of hectares of carbon-rich natural forest ecosystems and peatlands.

Ironically, spatial planning and licensing policies are frequently relaxed to expedite the realization of these projects, creating a glaring contradiction between conservation pledges abroad and extractive practices at home.

Spatial analysis data from MADANI Berkelanjutan based on 2024 maps reveals that 37.3 million hectares of natural forest lie outside the Indicative Map on the Suspension of New Permits (PIPPIB), of which 8.17 million hectares are primary natural forest. Meanwhile, natural forests overlapping with National Strategic Projects (PSN) for food and energy reserves span 8.78 million hectares.

The Irony of Climate Finance: When a Forest-Rich Nation Becomes a Donor

This situation gives rise to an irony that raises fundamental questions regarding climate justice and state budget priorities. Both historically and economically, Indonesia is a developing nation home to the world’s third-largest expanse of tropical forest, shouldered with a heavy ecological burden to maintain global climate stability.

Within the architecture of international climate negotiations, tropical forest-bearing developing countries should rightfully stand as recipients of financial support, technology transfer, and compensation from developed nations that bear historical responsibility for global carbon emissions.

The critical question that subsequently surfaces is: why is Indonesia instead positioning itself as a financial contributor of up to USD 1 billion into the TFFF scheme?

Amid constrained state fiscal space, urgent funding needs for climate adaptation among coastal communities, and meager operational budgets for conservation area management and the acceleration of customary forest recognition at home, pouring USD 1 billion in capital into a global financial instrument feels incongruous.

Although the government argues that the funds constitute an investment in an endowment fund whose principal remains intact and generates returns, there is still a massive opportunity cost when public funds of that magnitude are tied up in international financial markets rather than directly financing ecosystem protection and community welfare at the site level.

An Absolute Prerequisite: Aligning Development Direction with Ecosystem Protection

Special Envoy of the President of the Republic of Indonesia for Climate and Energy, Hashim S. Djojohadikusumo, who also serves as Head of the Indonesian Delegation at COP31 in Turkey (standing, center), during an Indonesia–Norway bilateral meeting at the Indonesia Pavilion, as part of the 31st United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP31) in Antalya, Turkey, on Thursday (November 12, 2026). Photo: MADANI Berkelanjutan

To escape this paradoxical trap, Indonesia must ensure that all national development policies are aligned with forest protection efforts. Ambitious climate diplomacy will never hold true meaning unless accompanied by policy corrections at the domestic level.

The government must make the protection of all remaining natural forest ecosystems—whether located within conservation areas, protection forests, or natural forests in other utilization areas (APL)—the primary foundation of development. A permanent moratorium on clearing natural forests and peatlands, a comprehensive review of PSN projects proven to destroy essential ecosystems, and strict law enforcement against forestry crime perpetrators are absolute prerequisites.

Without radical domestic governance reform, it will be impossible to sustainably optimize the financial benefits from the TFFF.

Dissecting the Blended Finance Mechanism and TFFF Performance Penalty Risks

The urgency of this domestic policy overhaul becomes even more critical when closely examining the design and operational mechanism of the TFFF itself. The TFFF is not an unconditional grant scheme disbursed freely, but rather a stringent performance-based climate finance instrument. Through a blended finance mechanism, initial capital from sponsoring countries such as Indonesia and Brazil is targeted to leverage private investment up to a total of USD 125 billion placed in a global bond portfolio.

The returns from these investments are then distributed to tropical forest countries at approximately USD 4 per hectare per year, based on their success in maintaining standing forest cover monitored transparently via satellite technology.

A boundary line separating PT Tunas Sawaerma's oil palm concession area from the remaining forest area in Ulilin District, Merauke Regency, South Papua, in 2016. (Photo: Mighty Earth / Auriga Nusantara)

Under the TFFF scheme, a country’s success is measured by its ability to keep annual deforestation rates below a 0.5 percent threshold, and even to expand tropical forest areas through restoration. Should a country fail to control deforestation rates or experience widespread forest fires, the TFFF system imposes severe incentive deductions or penalties ranging between USD 100 and USD 800 for every hectare of forest lost or degraded.

This means that if land-based PSN projects in Indonesia continue to clear natural forests and exceed the established deforestation threshold, the potential funds Indonesia should receive will be completely wiped out by penalties. Indonesia instead risks suffering a double loss: losing its own forest ecosystems while failing to reap financial benefits from the very facility it helped fund.

Reaffirming Indonesia’s Standing Point: Priority as a Beneficiary

What, then, should Indonesia’s strategic standing point be within the TFFF funding scheme? Is Indonesia better suited to act as a donor or as a beneficiary?

The answer is unequivocal: Indonesia must prioritize its position as a beneficiary country as well as a guardian of governance justice, rather than merely projecting prestige as a financial contributor.

As the steward of roughly 90.18 million hectares of remaining tropical forest cover as of 2024, Indonesia’s greatest and most invaluable contribution to the world is not USD 1 billion in cash, but the ecosystem services provided by its standing tropical forests. Therefore, in the implementation of the TFFF, Indonesia must demand that its status as a financial contributor does not obscure its rights as a developing country entitled to full beneficiary status.

Furthermore, the Indonesian government must ensure that every dollar received from the TFFF genuinely flows to strengthen the protection of remaining natural forests and guarantees that the mandatory minimum allocation of 20 percent is channeled directly to Indigenous Peoples and Local Communities without getting entangled in convoluted bureaucratic chains.

Ultimately, the USD 1 billion commitment proclaimed from the COP30 stage in Brazil to COP31 in Turkey will be judged not by the size of the pledged figure, but by how green Indonesia’s forest cover remains when monitored by the world's satellites.

Without the courage to halt deforestation legitimized by national development projects, Indonesia’s participation in the TFFF will amount to little more than an expensive diplomatic showcase, while our tropical forests continue to shrink in silence.

Related to read