The High Price of the Energy Transition: When Deforestation Masquerades as Saving the Climate in South Papua

The High Price of the Energy Transition: When Deforestation Masquerades as Saving the Climate in South Papua

Discover the preliminary findings of MADANI Berkelanjutan Foundation’s Environmental Carrying and Assimilative Capacity (D3TLH) study on the threats of deforestation and ecosystem damage caused by food and bioenergy National Strategic Project (PSN) allocations in Merauke.

Discover the preliminary findings of MADANI Berkelanjutan Foundation’s Environmental Carrying and Assimilative Capacity (D3TLH) study on the threats of deforestation and ecosystem damage caused by food and bioenergy National Strategic Project (PSN) allocations in Merauke.

No headings found on page
  • Food and bioenergy National Strategic Project (PSN) allocations in Merauke Regency, South Papua, have consumed roughly 40 percent of the regency's territory, the vast majority of which is still dominated by intact forest landscapes and wetland ecosystems.

  • The government’s narrative regarding the utilization of degraded land does not align with realities on the ground, as the program directly targets key biodiversity areas storing hundreds of millions of tons of aboveground carbon stocks.


  • Massive land clearing to pursue biofuel blending ambitions threatens the integrity of Peatland Hydrological Units (KHG) while severing the natural roaming ranges of Trans-Fly endemic wildlife.


  • On this basis, MADANI Berkelanjutan Foundation urges an immediate moratorium on all on-the-ground activities until a participatory Environmental Carrying and Assimilative Capacity (D3TLH) study is completed, ensuring that the energy transition does not come at the steep price of deforestation.

The government's ambition to establish a food and bioenergy hub at the easternmost tip of Indonesia evidently demands a very high price. In Merauke, South Papua, an area spanning 1.84 million hectares equivalent to nearly 40 percent of the regency's total area has now been designated under National Strategic Project (PSN) allocations, targeting intact natural landscapes and disregarding existing environmental carrying capacity limits.

This figure stems from the preliminary findings of an Environmental Carrying and Assimilative Capacity (D3TLH) study conducted by MADANI Berkelanjutan Foundation in collaboration with Lokahita Foundation, which was discussed in a focus group discussion in Bandung in mid-October 2026.

The same study found that only 3,775 hectares, or 0.2 percent of the PSN area, lies on critical land. The remainder occupies forests, swamps, savannas, and peatlands that are still actively performing their ecological functions. Portions of these lands even overlap with protection forests, Wasur National Park, Peatland Hydrological Units (KHG), and Key Biodiversity Areas (KBAs).

Escalating Bioenergy Ambitions

The boundary of the forest area that has been and will continue to be cleared for PT Papua Agro Lestari's oil palm plantation concession in Ulilin District, Merauke Regency, South Papua, in 2016. (Photo: Mighty Earth / Auriga Nusantara)

These findings emerge amid government efforts to accelerate its biofuel (BBN) blending ambitions. The government mandated the supply of B50 biodiesel effective July 1, 2026, through Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) Decree No. 257.K/EK.01/MEM.E/2026, with a transition period for B40 distribution lasting until September 30, 2026. For bioethanol, the government targets E5 in 2026, E10 in 2027, and E20 around 2028–2029, with the most frequently cited sugarcane land requirement standing at around 2 million hectares. The Cabinet Secretariat noted that these lands are spread across Java, Sumatra, Kalimantan, and Papua.

However, the policy direction for land provisioning to meet these biofuel ambitions is internally contradictory. At the Indonesia Sustainability Forum in Jakarta on October 6, 2026, Special Envoy of the President for International Trade and Multilateral Cooperation Mari Elka Pangestu stated that future food and biofuel production would be directed toward degraded lands. At the very same forum, Coordinating Minister for Food Affairs Zulkifli Hasan asserted that the E20 target necessitates opening new sugarcane plantations.

A day later, at the Investor Daily Summit, Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources Bahlil Lahadalia mentioned an E50 target. Meanwhile, Special Envoy of the President for Climate and Energy Hashim Djojohadikusumo stated that feedstocks for B50 to B100 would be sourced from "degraded forests," which he claimed span 12.7 million hectares. MADANI Berkelanjutan responded to these government officials' statements in its October 12, 2026 press release and a dedicated review on "degraded forests."

In Merauke, South Papua, those plans are already underway on the ground. Through Minister of Forestry Decree (SK) No. 591 of 2025, the government released 486,939 hectares of forest area in South Papua reclassifying it as non-forest area for food, energy, and water self-sufficiency zones. Indigenous peoples have challenged this ministerial decree at the Jakarta State Administrative Court (PTUN) since May 2026. Meanwhile, the Governor of South Papua stated that four sugarcane mills are currently under construction and targeted to begin production in 2027.

Measuring Merauke’s Ecological Limits

A boundary line separating PT Tunas Sawaerma's oil palm concession area from the remaining forest area in Ulilin District, Merauke Regency, South Papua, in 2016. (Photo: Mighty Earth / Auriga Nusantara)

This D3TLH study answers a single question: to what extent can Merauke’s natural landscape continue to sustain ecosystems and community livelihoods if all food and energy plans are realized? Historically, development impacts have generally been assessed on a sector-by-sector and permit-by-permit basis. No framework has existed to compare ecological conditions across spatial utilization scenarios cumulatively.

The study applies the environmental services (JLH) approach stipulated in Government Regulation (PP) No. 46/2017 on Environmental Economic Instruments. Lokahita built land-cover models for four points in time: 2005 as the baseline condition; 2015 following the Merauke Integrated Food and Energy Estate (MIFEE) program; 2025 as bioethanol and biodiesel PSNs take shape; and a 2035 projection assuming the full realization of PSNs. Each point in time is then evaluated across six ecosystem services: food provisioning, water provisioning, water regulation, air quality regulation, habitat and biodiversity, and carbon storage.

The study is conducted in two phases. The first phase (September–December 2026) maps land cover, ecosystem services, carbon stocks, and overlaps between PSNs and essential ecosystem areas. The second phase (2027) will assess water carrying capacity, the conversion of local food-producing lands, and tidal inundation, while comparing Merauke with other extractive regions in Eastern Indonesia. The findings presented here are interim results from the first phase and remain limited to the administrative boundaries of Merauke Regency.

First finding: The scale of PSNs and overlapping permits

Aerial photograph showing piles of felled timber prepared for burning in the prospective oil palm plantation area of PT Papua Alam Lestari in Ulilin District, Merauke Regency, South Papua, in 2016. (Photo: Mighty Earth / Auriga Nusantara)

The study analyzed three indicative PSN spatial layers most closely tied to biofuels and food: sugarcane plantation concessions covering 509,158 hectares (11% of Merauke's territory), oil palm plantation permits covering 1,144,493 hectares (24.7%), and food and energy reserve areas covering 853,217 hectares (18.4%). After accounting for overlapping areas, the total footprint reaches approximately 1.84 million hectares out of the regency's total area of roughly 4.64 million hectares.

These indicative permits heavily overlap with one another. Sugarcane concessions and oil palm permits intersect across 273,444 hectares more than half of the total sugarcane concession area. Food and energy reserve areas overlap by 317,290 hectares with oil palm permits and by 136,113 hectares with sugarcane concessions. Overlaps of this magnitude indicate that PSN spatial planning has not been formulated under a single, unified map.

Second finding: Merauke remains a landscape of forests and wetlands

A PT Papua Agro Lestari (PT PAL) foreman directs heavy equipment to gather and pile timber to be burned (the stacking process) in the concession area of Jair District, Boven Digoel Regency, Papua, in June 2016. Each year, the rate of forest destruction in Papua continues to rise for the expansion of oil palm plantations. (Photo: Mighty Earth / Auriga Nusantara)

The 2025 land-cover model developed by Lokahita using the Random Forest algorithm on Landsat imagery (82.37% overall accuracy, Kappa 0.79) mapped 21 land-cover classes. The results show that roughly 2.39 million hectares, or 51% of Merauke’s territory, remains natural forest. Primary dryland forest alone accounts for 788.5 thousand hectares (16.97%).

Wetland ecosystems comprising swamp forests, marshes, swamp scrubland, and mangroves span roughly 1.96 million hectares, or 42% of the regency. Savannas and grasslands, characteristic of the Trans-Fly landscape, cover 325.44 thousand hectares. Meanwhile, bare land accounts for only 15.19 thousand hectares, and settlements cover 62.18 thousand hectares.

Third finding: Indicative PSN locations are not directed toward degraded land

Critical and severely critical land in Merauke totals only 5,606 hectares. Of that amount, 3,775 hectares (67%) falls within indicative PSN areas. However, that figure represents a mere 0.2% of the total PSN footprint.

This finding aligns with national data. Minister of Forestry Decree No. 406 of 2025 records that critical land across the entire Province of South Papua amounts to just 47,014 hectares. The "degraded land" narrative cannot explain the expansion in Merauke, as this expansion is taking place outside critical lands.

Fourth finding: Indicative PSN locations overlap with protected areas, peatlands, and KBAs

Spatial overlay analysis between indicative PSN locations, essential ecosystem areas (KEE), and other key zones reveals the following interim results:

  • Conservation areas and protection forests: 20,716 hectares overlap with indicative PSN locations, comprising 13,927 hectares of protection forest, 4,133 hectares of Wasur National Park, 1,703 hectares of wildlife sanctuaries, and 954 hectares of nature reserves/nature recreation parks. The majority stems from oil palm permits. Wasur National Park is an internationally recognized wetland protected under the Ramsar Convention, and conservation areas as well as protection forests cannot be converted into plantations under Law No. 41/1999 on Forestry and Law No. 5/1990 in conjunction with Law No. 32/2024 on the Conservation of Living Natural Resources and Their Ecosystems (KSDAHE).


  • Peatland Hydrological Units (KHG): 85,988 hectares, or 51.2% of Merauke’s KHG, overlap with sugarcane concessions and oil palm permits. Peatland drainage triggers land subsidence, continuous carbon emissions, and heightened fire vulnerability.


  • Mangroves: 12,144 hectares, or 4.1% of mangrove ecosystems in Merauke, overlap with PSNs, primarily driven by oil palm permits. Mangroves protect coastlines and serve as vital habitats for fish and shrimp.


  • Key Biodiversity Areas (KBAs): 70,839 hectares, or 12.2% of Merauke’s KBAs, overlap with PSNs, with sugarcane concessions accounting for the largest share (63,844 hectares). While KBAs do not hold formal legal status, they serve as benchmarks for environmental safeguards among international financial institutions, including the critical habitat criteria under International Finance Corporation (IFC) Performance Standard 6.

Fifth finding: Fragmented wildlife habitats

The study mapped the indicative distribution of 10 priority wildlife species based on IUCN data. Indicative PSN locations overlap with 39.4% of the distribution range of priority mammals, reptiles, and fish, and 42.2% of priority birds. By species, the largest overlaps occur among:

  • Greater bird-of-paradise (Paradisaea apoda, protected): 55.3% of its range


  • Southern cassowary (Casuarius casuarius, protected): 42.2% of its range


  • Dusky pademelon (Thylogale brunii, vulnerable, protected): 42.4% of its range


  • Pig-nosed turtle (Carettochelys insculpta, endangered, protected): 39.5% of its range


  • Bronze quoll (Dasyurus spartacus, near threatened, Trans-Fly endemic): 29.7% of its range


Cassowaries are dispersers of large-seeded fruits that determine forest regeneration. River sedimentation resulting from land clearing also threatens the nesting habitats of the pig-nosed turtle. Because IUCN ranges depict potential presence, these figures are indicative and will be refined with field data.

Sixth finding: 567 million tons of carbon stored above ground

The boundary of the forest area that has been and will be cleared for PT Papua Agro Lestari's oil palm plantation concession area in June 2016. (Photo: Mighty Earth / Auriga Nusantara)

Based on 2025 land-cover modeling, carbon stocks in aboveground biomass across the Merauke study area are estimated at 567.24 million tons of carbon. Approximately 86.36% of this is stored within natural forest categories, with primary dryland forest contributing 263.47 million tons and secondary swamp forest contributing 40.39 million tons. This calculation remains a preliminary estimate restricted to aboveground biomass, excluding belowground biomass and soil organic carbon, including peat. Consequently, potential emissions from land-cover conversion under each PSN scenario still require further calculation and will be presented in the final first-phase report.

Ecosystem services modeling also identifies areas with high to very high potential for air quality regulation, food provisioning, and biodiversity, alongside high potential for water regulation. This assessment reflects potential ecosystem services based on ecosystem characteristics and land cover, rather than direct measurements of community utilization of those services.

“These are still preliminary findings, yet the pattern is already clear. PSN areas in Merauke sit on landscapes consisting of forests, swamps, savannas, and peatlands not on already degraded land. In the next stage, we are modeling a 2035 scenario to calculate how much ecosystem services and carbon will be lost if all of these plans are realized,” said Dr. Akhmad Riqqi, Geospatial and Ecology Expert at Lokahita Foundation.

Heading to COP31: Large-scale climate solutions, large-scale risks

The 31st UN Climate Change Conference (COP31) will take place in Antalya, Turkey, on November 9–20, 2026. Turkey serves as host and leads the action agenda, while Australia presides over the negotiations. One of the most anticipated items on the agenda is the follow-up to the COP30 roadmap on transitioning away from fossil fuels and halting deforestation.

Indonesia arrives in Antalya carrying the narrative of Delivering Climate Solutions at Scale. The Indonesian delegation, led by Hashim Djojohadikusumo, will offer carbon market development and the rehabilitation of 12.3 million hectares of forest to attract international support. Meanwhile, the Indonesia Pavilion highlights clean energy transition and nature-based solutions as two of its five main topics.

Here lies the crux of the problem. The land area figure brought to Antalya for rehabilitation is nearly identical to the "degraded forest" figure pitched to investors a month earlier as a source of biofuel feedstock. In Merauke, biofuels are not being developed on degraded lands, but across forest, peatland, and savanna landscapes storing hundreds of millions of tons of carbon. If the energy transition is paid for through deforestation, carbon emissions are not reduced they merely shift from tailpipes to forests.

“The government will bring a narrative of large-scale climate solutions to Antalya. Our preliminary study findings in Merauke show that this scale applies equally to the risks: nearly 40 percent of a single regency's territory has been allocated for food and energy without a transparent carrying capacity assessment. An energy transition built upon the loss of forests, peatlands, and the living spaces of Indigenous peoples cannot be called a climate solution,” said Giorgio Budi Indrarto, Executive Board Member of MADANI Berkelanjutan Foundation.

MADANI Berkelanjutan will attend COP31 as an observer organization and bring these preliminary findings to forums in Antalya. Its message is straightforward: every biofuel blending target must first be tested against environmental carrying capacity before being translated into land-area targets.

MADANI Berkelanjutan’s Demands

Based on these preliminary findings, MADANI Berkelanjutan urges the government to:

  • Halt all new land clearing across the entire Merauke PSN area until a transparent and participatory Environmental Carrying and Assimilative Capacity (D3TLH) study is completed.


  • Exclude conservation areas, protection forests, Peatland Hydrological Units (KHG), mangroves, and Key Biodiversity Areas (KBAs) from PSN zones, including already issued oil palm permits and sugarcane concessions.


  • Establish D3TLH studies as a mandatory prerequisite before B50, E20, and subsequent biofuel blending targets are translated into national or regional land-area targets.


  • Refrain from using the "degraded land" narrative to justify expansion in Merauke, as data demonstrates that this expansion is taking place across still-functioning natural landscapes.


  • Disclose spatial data on PSNs, permits, and their overlaps at a scale verifiable on the ground, and involve the Malind Indigenous Peoples and local communities in determining spatial governance.


  • Ensure that climate solution claims presented at COP31 do not rely on biofuel programs that risk triggering deforestation and peatland drainage.

These preliminary findings, including 2005–2025 land-cover dynamics, will be presented in greater detail during a media briefing by MADANI Berkelanjutan and Lokahita Foundation in November 2026.

Related to read