
Dokumen Indonesia:
Declaring the Development of the Indigenous Law Society Bill
The draft Law (RUU) of the Indigenous Peoples of Indigenous Law (MHA) is one of the bills that are strongly encouraged by the ratification by various parties from the leadership of President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono to the leadership of President Joko Widodo. Various instruments of national and international law also encourage the existence of arrangements to protect the rights of indigenous peoples.
The urgency of the ratification of the MHA Bill is increasingly felt in the view of the many cases of violations of the rights of indigenous peoples. Madani's spatial analysis found several things that could add to the potential violation of the rights of indigenous peoples, including:
Of the 9.3 million hectares of Identified Indigenous territories, there are 8.5 million hectares of overlapping areas with permits/concessions and Indicative Map of Restrictions on the Granting of New Permits (PIPPIB) or moratorium area of forests and peatlands;
The widest overlap occurred between the Indigenous Region and PIPPIB covering an area of 4.1 million hectares, followed by a 1.1 million hectares of oil palm plantation permit, and oil and gas concessions covering an area of 1 million hectares.
There are 190 thousand hectares of Indigenous Areas covered in the Area of Interest (AoI) Food Estate in 4 Provinces (North Sumatra, South Sumatra, Central Kalimantan, and Papua), the widest in Papua of 123 thousand hectares, followed by 66 thousand hectares.
In addition to overlapping with permits / consumption, the Area of Interest (AoI) of Food Estate, and PIPPIB, Madani's analysis also found that there are still many natural forests and peat ecosystems in the Indigenous Region, each covering an area of 5.6 million hectares and 878 thousand hectares. This can be an opportunity to support efforts to fulfill Indonesia’s climate commitment in the forestry and land use sectors. The reason, the document Nationally Determined Contribution or NDC Indonesia has recognized traditional wisdom (local wisdom) as a matter that can be part of efforts to reduce emissions. Therefore, the role of indigenous peoples in maintaining environmental balance is also worthy of attention.
Various impetuses to speed up the ratification of the MHA bill have sprung up, but the process is still very slow. The MHA bill has entered into Prolegnas (national legislation program) in 2013, 2017, and 2020. However, the endorsement of the MHA Bill is still 'overtapped' by other bills such as Law No. 11 on Work Creation and Revision of the Minerba Act. This year, the MHA Bill is back in the Priority Prolegnas and is currently still in the stage of harmonization. However, the involvement
The community in the discussion of the MHA Bill is still minimal. Various consultations conducted to various elements of civil society during this time including during the time of the Covid-19 pandemic still have not been felt as a "pure" consultation. When viewed from the concept of the level of public participation of Sherry Arnstein, community participation in the discussion of the MHA Bill is considered still "tokenistic" or pseudo-participation.
Many fundamental inputs from indigenous organizations, civil society, and academics who have not been accommodated in the draft of the MHA Bill even though it has been repeatedly proposed.1 There are several debates that often arise in the discussion of the substance of the MHA Bill, including differences in terms and elements in the definition of MHA, the mechanism of recognition of MHA which tends to be political and convoluted, as well as the scope of protection of MHA rights that have been formally recognized. In addition, there are still important issues that have not been included in the scope of the regulation of the MHA Bill, among them the collective rights of Indigenous Women and the mechanism of restoration of MHA rights.
In addition to these various debates, there are indications that the slow discussion of the MHA Bill occurred due to the magnitude of the political economy that colored the process in which conflicts of interest are difficult to avoid. In addition, the issuance of Law No. 11 on Job Creation adds to the length of the challenges facing MHA, especially in the harmonization of the substance of the bill.
It is suspected that there are two factors that hinder the acceleration of the ratification of the MHA Bill. PertamaFirst, the economic-political factor, where currently the majority (55%) of the members of the House of Representatives are businessmen (318 out of 575). This reinforces indications of conflicts of interest in the drafting of legislation, including in the drafting of the MHA Bill. Second, the passing of the Work Creation Law along with its derivative regulations have the potential to add to the long list of problems faced by MHA so that recognition of indigenous peoples increasingly runs in place.
Get Madani’s Insight June 2021 “Intended the Development of the Indigenous Law Society Bill” by downloading the attachments available below.



